• Ballpark Brawl
  • Natural Heavyweight Championship (1 time)[29]
• CBS Sports
  • Smack Talker of the Year (2018)[30]
• Extreme Wrestling Federation
  • Xtreme 8 Tournament (2006)[31]
• Independent Wrestling Association Mid-South
  • Revolution Strong Style Tournament (2004)[2]
• Pro Wrestling Illustrated
  • Feud of the Year (2007)[32] vs. Kurt Angle
  • Most Popular Wrestler of the Year (2006)[33]
  • PWI ranked him #4 of the 500 best singles wrestlers in the PWI 500 in 2006 and 2008[34][35]
• Pro Wrestling Noah
  • GHC Tag Team Championship (1 time) – with Magnus[20]
• Pro Wrestling Zero-One
  • NWA Intercontinental Tag Team Championship (1 time)1[11][12] – with Keiji Sakoda
• Pure Wrestling Association
  • PWA Pure Wrestling Championship (1 time)[2]
• Ring of Honor
  • ROH Pure Championship (1 time)[36][16]
  • ROH World Championship (1 time)[37][15]
• SoCal Uncensored
  • Rookie of the Year (2000)[38]
• Total Nonstop Action Wrestling
  • TNA Television Championship (1 time)[13]
  • TNA World Heavyweight Championship (1 time)[8]
  • TNA World Tag Team Championship (2 times) – by himself (1)2 and Magnus (1)[8][19]
  • TNA X Division Championship (5 times)[8]
  • King of the Mountain (2008)[17]
  • Maximum Impact Tournament (2011)[39]
  • TNA X Division Championship Tournament (2014)
  • Super X Cup (2005)[2]
  • Feast or Fired (2009 – World Heavyweight Championship contract)
  • TNA Turkey Bowl (2007)[2]
  • Gauntlet for the Gold (2007 – TNA World Heavyweight Championship)[40]
  • Wild Card Tournament (2011) – with Magnus[18]
  • Third TNA Grand Slam Champion[14]
  • Third TNA Triple Crown Champion[8]
  • Mr. TNA (2006, 2007)[41]
  • X Division star of the Year (2006)[41]
  • Feud of the Year (2006–2007) with Kurt Angle[41][42]
  • Finisher of the Year (2007) Muscle buster[42]
• Twin Wrestling Entertainment
  • TWE Heavyweight Championship (1 time)[2]
• Ultimate Pro Wrestling
  • UPW Heavyweight Championship (1 time)[43]
  • UPW No Holds Barred Championship (1 time)[43]
• United Independent Wrestling Alliance
  • UIWA Tag Team Championship (2 times)[2]
• Wrestling Observer Newsletter
  • Best Brawler (2005, 2006)[44]
  • Match of the Year (2005) vs. Kenta Kobashi, ROH Joe vs. Kobashi, October 1
  • Most Outstanding Wrestler (2005)
• WWE
  • WWE United States Championship (2 times)
  • NXT Championship (2 times)
  • Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic (2015) – with Finn Bálor[24]

1 After the title was vacated, Joe and Sakoda's reign was stricken from the promotion's records.

2 Joe held the title by himself during his first reign.